Quality: 9/10. Gray market, tags cut. There was a small (3/4in) pull or repair on the back, but it's not noticeable when worn. Otherwise, exactly like retail. Thin and smooth weave.
Accuracy: 9/10. Tags removed, but buttons are branded.
Satisfaction: 9/10. Don't pay retail prices for AllSaints. I'm not sure if I will buy more gray market AllSaints; I can find preowned for roughly the same price on Posh/TheRealReal/etc.