Quality: 9/10. I got these to wear around the house, not outside. I specifically wanted a rubber sole (quieter) and faux fur. I'm not opposed to real fur, but something about walking around on it makes me think of stepping on roadkill, and that isn't pleasant. These are real leather, and the leather isn't stiff - they don't crease as much as the auth or rep Princetowns. My Princetowns from Tong don't fit me well; they're too loose, and thus the creases that formed make them look like clown shoes. These dupes fit me much better. There was a little spot of glue near the sole on one shoe, but it was easy enough to remove.
Accuracy: N/A. The shape is pretty close, but the horsebit and sole are different than auth.
Satisfaction: 10/10. Perfect for house slippers, but not for wearing in public if you care about auth details.