ACCURACY SCORE: 5/10
I don't think I'm fully qualified to answer about accuracy b/c I don't know how or where logos should be placed (there is a "Goyard" logo embossed on inside of the pouch, though). However, the Y's are just about touching and the color I rate a 9/10. The color of the Y's look on this cheap replica better than "mirror image" Goyards in white.
However, the Taobao sellers of this bag labeled this size as "large" (GM), and they are way, way off... This size is nearly equivalent to that of the St. Louis PM. Dimensions of this bag, here, lack DEPTH! It's infuriating. If the size weren't so inaccurate and if the handles were leather, the canvas could pass for authentic (provided that the wrinkles smooth out in time).
QUALITY SCORE: 7/10
However, I haven't worn the bag long enough to see if the threading will keep the bag together. Also, the handles, I'm sure, aren't leather.
AGENT COMMUNICATION & SERVICE SCORE: 9/10
The agent has excellent communication. However, I get hit with fees twice b/c they have a general service fee and they pass along their PayPal payment fees to the client.